Have a theological question?
Visit Got Questions →Blog
The Composite Nature of Agape
19 October 2026
Matthew 5: 43 – 48; Mark 12: 28 -34
When Scripture speaks of the love of God, its context remains a definitive guide to what the writer intended to convey. For instance, there is the intra-Trinitarian love (John 3:35) or the beneficial love for all mankind - the good and the evil (Matt 5:44-45), the salvific love for the lost (John 3:16) or the elective love for certain others (Rom 9:10-13; 1 Thess 1:4), or love for the obedient (John 14:15).
However, to focus strictly on one rationale for agape to the exclusion of others would merely make a mockery of what God intended: viz., if we were to interpret that He only loves those who are ‘good,’ then merit-making seems likely to become our focus, or if His love is based on His ‘strict’ election, then evangelism and prayer may seem to be superfluous.
When God addressed the issue of loving His enemies (Matt 5:43), He is not referring to His redemptive nor His elective love, but that He gives His temporal blessings to all.
Although we may differentiate ‘love,’ these references share the same Greek root word agape, the word God used for Himself (1 John 4:8). Consequently, agape is composite. It is made up of strands woven into one cord. Yahweh’s variable motivation for agape varies for diverse settings, but the quality and depth of it remains constant.
How then can we define agape? Agape is the self-giving love that seeks the good of another.
When challenged by the scribes to name the most important commandment, Jesus’ emphatic reply was, “The foremost is, Hear O Israel! The Lord our God is one Lord; and you shall love the Lord your God with all your heart, and with all your soul, and with all your mind, and with all your strength.
The second is this, you shall love your neighbour as yourself. There is no other commandment greater than these” (Mark 12:30-31). His answer was drawn from the Shema (Deut 6:4-9), which Jews continue to repeat at least twice daily to this day.
Notice the totality of agape mentioned in the Shema: all the heart, soul, mind, and strength. Hence, agape toward God is not a Sunday emotion; it engages our affections, our will, our thinking, and our energy. God is not given a corner of our life, He is loved with the whole of it.
Jesus then adds the agape towards one’s neighbour: “The second is this: Love your neighbour as yourself.” The two cannot be separated. The scribe who questioned Him recognized this immediately, saying that such love is “more important than all burnt offerings and sacrifices” (v. 33).
So, love for God that never reaches our neighbour is incomplete, and love for neighbour cut off from God, will soon runs dry.
When it was originally propounded, the principal objective was to distinguish Israel’s spirituality from the surrounding nations: Yahweh is the only One that matters to them for all their varied needs, not the pantheon of gods and goddesses, each for a diverse season and requirement.
They were to cherish and worship Him with their whole self-identity, because they were made in His image. Hence, to worship anything or anyone else is viewed as flagrant idolatry. The Shema implies that when they sinned, it was due to their infraction against God Himself (c.f., Lev 19 and the repeated the suffix: I am the Lord); where neglect of the first commandment led to sinfulness in every sphere of their personal world.
Even though the public justice system demanded ‘an eye for an eye,’ personal revenge is undeniably eschewed in the Mosaic Law and by Jesus (Lev 19:17-18; Matt 5:44-45), to end the interminable enmity and bitterness seeded by a motive to exact retribution.
God reminds us that He sends rain on both the just as well as the unjust, and He had declared that He will be the final Judge on behalf of the righteous (Rom 12:78-21).
How does one transcend evil especially when persecution is directed towards one? It needs to be clarified that loving our enemies cannot be our consummate desire, it cannot replace loving our God. Natural love is reciprocal, as we love those who love us.
Agape is modelled differently; it is modelled on the Father. Agape gives, without calculating who deserves it. Without doubt, God expects His people to embrace the ‘agape’ that exists within the Trinity unreservedly, simply due to the fact that Christ inhabits all believers born again by the Spirit of God (John 17:24-26).
The Spirit of Christ constraints us as we seek to obey God’s command even to love our enemies, and even when we do find that to be humanly challenging, He encourages us to turn to prayer for them (Matt 5:44). For it is in this intercessory mode that we begin to discover the hideousness of our soul engendered by our hatred for our enemies (c.f., 1 John 2:9-11).
John’s words are searching: “The one who says, ‘I have come to know Him,’ and does not keep His commandments, is a liar” (I John 2:3-6). John, here, gives a practical test of genuine fellowship with God, for those who truly know Christ will seek to obey Him.
A profession that remains untouched by obedience is empty. Christian faith is not merely an intellectual belief or verbal profession; it produces a changed pattern of life. To know God personally is to recognize Him as Lord and to respond to His revealed will.
Such knowledge is not merely information about Christ, but fellowship with Him that reshapes our desires and conduct; it reveals that God’s saving grace and love is truly at work in us.
John is not teaching sinless perfection. Earlier, he affirmed that believers may stumble, but that Christ is their Advocate; therefore, keeping God’s commandments means a settled direction of obedience, repentance, and faith, not flawless performance. The true Christian may fall, but does not make peace with disobedience.
“Whoever keeps His word, in him the love of God has truly been perfected” (1 John 2:5). God’s agape reaches its intended expression when it produces loving obedience. We do not obey in order to persuade God to love us; we obey because His love has already taken hold of us. Love for God and obedience to Him belong together, just as love for our neighbour fulfils the heart of His commandments.
Finally, John says that the one who claims to abide in Christ “ought himself to walk in the same manner as He walked” (1 John 2:6). Jesus is not merely our Saviour, He is also our ‘pattern.’ His walk was marked by humility, purity, compassion, truth, prayer, and complete submission to the Father.
To abide in Christ is, therefore, to remain close to Him in such a way that His character increasingly appears in our lives.
Agape, then, is:
- Wholehearted, given to God with all that we are;
- Outward-reaching, expressed to the neighbour beside us;
- Boundary-breaking, extended even to those who oppose us; and
- Active, shown in prayer, kindness, and sacrifice, not merely in sentiment.
Remove one strand and the cord weakens. Love for God without love for neighbour becomes hollow religion. Love for neighbour without love for enemy becomes ‘tribal’ kindness. Love for enemy without love for God becomes an impossible burden carried in our own strength.
About Coram Deo
Coram Deo — before the face of God. This blog reflects on Scripture, world events, science, music, psychology, and the human mind — always through the lens of Christian faith. All of life is lived before the face of God.